Selecting the best platform to share your writing can impact your journey as a content creator. Medium offers a broad audience, making it a great starting point for gaining visibility. Substack, conversely, emphasizes building a direct relationship with your readers through newsletters. 

In this article, we'll break down the key differences between these platforms, exploring their unique features, monetization models, and community aspects to help you determine which best aligns with your goals. 

As you consider your options, remember that true success often lies in owning your audience and diversifying your revenue streams, an important principle we'll explore further. 

‍

Overview of Substack and Medium Platform

When it comes to building your online writing presence, Substack and Medium offer two distinct paths to success. Medium is all about visibility and discovery; on the other hand, Substack is more focused on long-term growth and community-building. 

Both of these platforms are great if you want to make your voice heard in the crowded world of content creation. Going ahead, we will understand these platforms in depth.

‍

Substack

Substack is a platform that lets writers create and send out newsletters, helping them connect with their audience, share content, and make money through paid subscriptions. 

Substack has gained popularity due to its simplicity and ease of use, allowing writers to manage their newsletters without technical expertise. It also provides tools for engaging with the audience through comments and discussions, creating a sense of community.

While Substack is an excellent choice, it may be more suitable for intermediate or advanced writers.

‍

Medium

Medium is a platform for sharing articles and ideas, launched by Twitter co-founder Evan Williams. It’s a great place for beginner writers to get started, share their stories, and reach a broad audience without the complexity of building a subscriber list.

The platform’s minimalist design focuses on the content, making it easy for readers to engage with the material. A standout feature of Medium is its Partner Program, where writers can earn money based on reader engagement. 

‍

Substack vs Medium: Audience and Reach

Substack's emphasis on targeted communities makes it ideal for niche content creators, fostering a loyal and engaged audience. It attracts the audience, particularly those interested in specific topics like politics, technology, and personal development. 

With direct access to your subscribers via email, you can build a close, personal relationship without the interference of algorithms or platform restrictions. While Substack lacks a built-in discovery mechanism, successful newsletters can still gain viral traction through social media, word-of-mouth, and cross-promotion. 

It has a global reach, making it suitable for creators targeting international readers. If you’re looking to build a loyal, niche community with direct access, Substack is a strong choice.

Medium has a larger internal audience than Substack (60 million vs. 30 million monthly visitors). Unlike Substack's focus on building direct relationships through newsletters, Medium operates more as a community-driven content hub. Similar to social media platforms, Medium offers an extensive network of readers and followers who actively seek out interesting content.

While Medium offers a vast network of readers, visibility depends on the platform's algorithms and curation system. 

Medium is well-suited for writers looking to gain exposure, build a following, and establish themselves as thought leaders in their respective fields. The platform's built-in distribution network and SEO benefits can help writers reach a broader audience than they might otherwise achieve.

‍

Substack vs Medium: Features & Functionality

As discussed in the above section, Substack is a newsletter-centric platform that allows you to create and distribute newsletters directly to your subscribers’ inboxes. Let’s take a look at some of the other functionalities that help you build personal connections and engage them through email.

1. Customizable Websites: Every Substack publication gets its own customizable website where you can archive all your posts, providing your readers with a centralized hub to access both past and present content.
2. Community Building Tools: Engage your readers with features like comment sections, discussion threads, and tools that let your audience interact with you and each other.
3. Substack Notes: Use the Notes feature as a social media feed to post short-form content and share thoughts, links, and quotes. This helps increase discoverability and can drive more subscriptions.
4. Expanded Media Formats: Substack supports various media types, including podcasts and videos, allowing you to attach audio files to your posts.
5. Analytics and Insights: Track your open rates, subscriber growth, and traffic data to understand how your audience engages with your content.
6. Compatibility and Integrations: You can import content from other platforms like Mailchimp, WordPress, and more, ensuring a smooth transition to Substack without losing your previous content.

Medium offers a wide range of functions and features for readers and content creators.

1. User-Friendly Platform: Medium offers an online platform for reading and writing with social-media-like features. Paid subscribers gain access to unlimited stories, while free members can only read non-paywalled content.
2. Content Creation and Formatting: Medium provides an easy and intuitive editor for creating and formatting articles, including options for headings, lists, images, and embedded multimedia content. It allows you to create visually appealing articles with rich media elements, as well as add custom code snippets.
3. Vast User Base and Distribution: The platform's algorithms and curation system, including an 'editor's choice' newsletter, help surface content to relevant readers, increasing the chances of visibility and engagement.
4. Community Engagement: Medium fosters a sense of community through features such as comments, highlights, and recommendations. As readers engage with articles, Medium's algorithms take note and surface the content to a similar section of the audience.

‍

Substack vs Medium: Business Models and Monetization

Substack offers a free model, no matter how many subscribers you have. It is designed to put you, the writer, in control of your work and your income.

• You can publish your original content straight to your subscribers through a newsletter. It's your voice, your content, delivered directly.
• Substack makes it easy to set up paid subscriptions, giving you the tools to manage your subscribers and create exclusive content they'll pay for.
• You have the freedom to offer both free and paid content, letting your readers sample your work and decide if they want to subscribe for more.
• Substack puts you in charge by combining publishing, payments, and analytics into one seamless system.
• Substack empowers you to build and monetize your audience directly, cutting out the middlemen and putting more money in your pocket.
• It is free for you to use the platform, create a newsletter, and grow your subscriber base.
• Supporters all over the world can access your content.
• While publishing on Substack is free, the platform charges a 10% commission fee for paid subscriptions. Additionally, Stripe charges payment processing fees: 2.9% + 30 cents per transaction and 0.5% for recurring payments.

Medium operates on a freemium model where subscribers access premium stories, and a portion of the subscription fees is then shared with the content creators. 

• Medium generates revenue primarily through subscription fees. Users pay either $5 per month or $50 per year for access to premium stories and publications.
• Medium uses a mix of AI and editorial picks to show potentially interesting content to users.
• It collaborates with larger publication groups (e.g., Sports Illustrated, The Economist) to distribute content on its platform.
• As per the business model, writers are compensated based on the amount of reading time their content accumulates.
• The site design is minimalistic, with a focus on readability and the removal of distractions like display ads.

Unlike Substack and Medium, which focus on subscription-based written content and algorithmic content distribution, respectively, SuperProfile serves as a link-in-bio tool to aggregate and directly monetize various digital products, courses, webinars, and community access across different social media platforms.

SuperProfile operates on a freemium model, providing content creators with a suite of tools to showcase and monetize their work, primarily targeting nano and micro-influencers. 

‍

Substack vs Medium: Monetization Options

Substack can be a substantial revenue source with a proper commitment and a strong strategy. Let’s take a look at some of the monetization options.

1. Paid Newsletter: You can monetize your Substack by offering a paid tier to your newsletter. Readers subscribe for a monthly or annual fee to access exclusive content that you gate. Substack takes a 10% commission on all subscription revenue, so factor that into your pricing and revenue projections.
2. Sponsorships and Advertisements: Incorporate paid sponsorships and advertisements into your newsletters, but remember that Substack itself is designed to be ad-free. You can feature sponsored content, product reviews, or brand mentions within your newsletter. 
3. Affiliate Links: Earn commissions by including affiliate links in your content when you recommend products or services to your readers. If a reader makes a purchase through your link, you can earn a percentage of the sale.
4. Digital or Physical Products: Consider selling digital or physical products through your Substack. Digital offerings could include e-books, templates, or online courses, while physical products might consist of branded merchandise or a book. 

Here's a breakdown of Medium's monetization options:

1. Medium Partner Program (MPP): This is the primary way to earn money on Medium. You get paid based on how long Medium members spend reading your stories, as well as the engagement your content generates, such as claps. To be eligible, you need to be accepted into the MPP. Medium members pay a subscription fee, and their $5 is distributed to writers based on their engagement with their work.
2. Referred Memberships: You can earn a portion of a new member's subscription fee for each non-paying user that you convert to a paying Medium member. You get a unique referral link that you can share on your posts, across social media, or on your Medium profile. For each referral, you earn roughly $2.
3. Affiliate Marketing: You can include affiliate links to products or services within your Medium stories and earn a commission when readers make a purchase through your links.
4. Selling Stuff/Driving Traffic to Your Website: Use Medium as a company blog and link to your website to drive traffic to landing pages or other parts of your sales funnel to promote your products, services, or consulting. 

SuperProfile offers flexible monetization options that creators can leverage using the platform:

• Sell Paid Memberships: You can offer exclusive access to your Discord or Telegram communities through paid memberships, adding value for your audience. 
• Digital Products and Courses: SuperProfile enables you to sell eBooks, online courses, and other exclusive digital content directly to your audience. The platform offers a no-code interface for efficient course creation, allowing you to offer videos, webinars, brochures, or downloadable materials.
• Events and Webinars: You can schedule events, sell tickets, and manage registrations seamlessly through SuperProfile. This feature is ideal for hosting workshops, live Q&A sessions, or webinars for a fee.
• One-on-One Sessions: SuperProfile streamlines the process of offering personalized coaching or consulting sessions, including scheduling and payment processing. This is useful for niches like fitness, career guidance, and digital marketing.

‍

Pros and Cons of Substack vs Medium

Substack excels at direct monetization through paid subscriptions, giving writers full ownership of their content and a dedicated audience, while Medium provides wider reach and content discovery through its large user base. Let’s weigh some more pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.

‍

‍

Conclusion

In conclusion, both Substack and Medium offer distinct opportunities for content creators. Substack is perfect for those who want to build a direct, loyal subscriber base and are committed to monetization through paid subscriptions. It offers full control over your content and revenue, making it ideal for intermediate or advanced writers looking to cultivate a niche audience. 

Medium, on the other hand, is great for writers seeking visibility and broad exposure, with its built-in community and wide reach.

If you want to take your content creation and monetization to the next level, consider exploring SuperProfile—a platform that combines the best of both worlds, giving you the tools to showcase your work, build a community, and seamlessly monetize through memberships, digital products, events, and one-on-one sessions.